The tuxedo has held its place at the top of the formality hierarchy since 1886, when it was first worn at Tuxedo Park, New York, as a deliberate simplification of white-tie evening dress. It removed ornamentation rather than adding it, which is why the look has never really dated — there was very little to go out of fashion in the first place. The oxford shoes traditionally paired with it follow the same logic: a plain, closed-lacing silhouette built on restraint rather than decoration.
At Zarssen, that same instinct shapes how we think about formal footwear — understanding why the tuxedo has held its position for more than a century says something useful about what a genuinely formal shoe is supposed to do.
A Dress Code Built by Subtraction
Most formalwear evolves by addition — a new cut, a new detail, a new flourish layered onto what came before. The tuxedo did the opposite. It emerged as a subtraction from full white tie: the tailcoat replaced by a plain jacket, the waistcoat simplified, the stiff formality of the era pared back to what actually mattered. Garments built on restraint have comparatively little to lose their relevance, which is largely why a tuxedo from decades ago still reads as correct today.
Why the Rules Around Black Tie Never Really Relaxed
Business dress has spent the past decade in genuine retreat — looser collars, optional ties, jackets that stay in the car more often than not. Black tie has barely moved. A dress code only relaxes when enough people wear it often enough to find its strictness inconvenient, and black tie shows up a handful of times a year for most of the people who own it — which has left its logic largely untouched by the casualization reshaping almost everything else.
Where Oxford Shoes Complete the Formality
The traditional black-tie shoe — a plain-toe or cap-toe oxford in black patent leather or high-shine calf — isn't an arbitrary pairing. Its closed lacing and unbroken silhouette follow the same subtractive logic as the jacket above it. A derby's open lacing, by comparison, introduces a small but real break in that formality, which is exactly why oxford shoes have remained the correct choice with a tuxedo, not an interchangeable one.
What a Well-Chosen Pair Actually Does
At a formal event, most of what gets noticed is absence, not excellence. Nobody registers a correctly chosen oxford; they register a derby that shouldn't be there, or a scuff that shouldn't have made it past the door. Zarssen's own oxford styles are built with that job specifically in mind: a plain, wholecut
silhouette in black calf, finished without ornament, designed to disappear correctly into the rest of the outfit rather than compete with it.
The tuxedo will likely still be doing the same job in another hundred years, for the same reason it's done it for the last one. A well-chosen pair of oxford shoes, built on that same restraint, tends to earn the same kind of staying power.
FAQs
What shoes are traditionally worn with a tuxedo?
Traditionally, a plain-toe or cap-toe oxford in black patent leather or high-shine calf, worn without decorative stitching or broguing. The closed lacing and unembellished silhouette match the tuxedo's own restraint, which is why oxfords remain the standard recommendation for black tie.
Are patent leather shoes required for black tie, or will regular black leather work?
Patent leather is the traditional choice, but a well-polished calf-leather oxford is now widely accepted outside the most formal or traditional black-tie events. What matters more is a smooth, unembellished silhouette, not the specific material.
Can derby shoes or loafers work with a tuxedo?
Not traditionally. Derbies and loafers have open lacing or no lacing at all, which reads as less formal than the closed-lacing oxford — a distinction rooted in the same formality hierarchy that separates business and black-tie dress more broadly.
- The tuxedo has remained largely unchanged since 1886 because it was built by removing ornament, not adding it.
- Black tie has resisted the broader casualization of business and formal dress because it's worn rarely, not daily.
- A well-chosen pair of oxford shoes completes the tuxedo's logic of restraint — precision without decoration.
- At a formal event, a shoe's job is usually to avoid drawing attention, not to attract it.
The same restraint the tuxedo requires is what Zarssen designs its oxford shoes toward.
DISCOVER THE COLLECTION
ABOUT ZARSSEN
Zarssen is a Dubai-based footwear house producing Italian-made leather shoes for men who dress with intention. Working directly with artisans across Italy, Zarssen builds formal and everyday footwear around a quiet, considered aesthetic — designed to support a look rather than announce itself.